Outside voices and views for advisers

Are you walking into a TDF trap?

Outdated assumptions about younger investors risk harming their returns

Jan 22, 2018 @ 1:26 pm

By David M. Haviland

Few investment products currently garner more attention than target date funds. Launched 30 years ago, TDFs are the most common qualified default investment alternative used in 401(k)s today, and they claim a sizable portion of the average investor's retirement portfolio.

It's surprising then that as advisers, we are so bad at selecting TDFs that actually work as our clients believe they will.

By recommending products based on outdated models and assumptions, advisers often lead clients into risks they don't need and traps they don't want. It's time to leave old habits behind and ensure clients avoid typical TDF mistakes: unhelpful diversification, flawed glidepath strategies and unwanted risk.


We've all prayed at the altar of asset diversification. It's the most basic portfolio protection strategy. And in "normal" market conditions, asset allocation and diversity can help. However, markets are not always normal.

During bear markets, asset-class risk often correlates towards one and diversity offers little defensive benefit. In 2008, world equity markets failed as did the diversifiers, such as gold. Today's TDF fund managers are still relying on this "de-worsifying" approach by adding riskier master limited partnerships, real estate investment trusts and other sub-equity classes to funds.

Many are also adding large amounts of junk and emerging-market bonds to compete on performance. But these are not "safe" and they too tend to correlate with equities in tough economic times. All asset classes suffer from bear markets, and many of these so-called diversifiers have performed even worse than the S&P 500.


Each TDF employs a glidepath — a formula to rebalance assets annually to reduce risk as the targeted date approaches. Most glidepaths are set on a predetermined asset allocation trajectory that slowly reduces equity exposure over time. But they are nothing more than a series of diversified asset allocations.

Worse yet, when glidepaths were last tested in 2008, many crashed. The 2010 TDFs of the largest providers lost between 21% and 31% in 2008. If your clients lost almost a third of their savings within two years of retirement, could they still afford to retire? Not most people.

If you haven't reviewed your recommended TDFs' glidepath strategies, do so immediately. You may be saving your clients from a very hard landing.


Possibly the biggest mistake TDF managers make is not listening to what clients want. Thus, we just repeatedly follow our own outdated misconceptions.

Today's youngest investors want and can handle the most risk, right? Wrong! This long-held belief is based only on the long recovery times young investors have. However, this strategy contradicts the fact that most young investors want conservative growth.

According to a recent Cerulli Associates study, only 7% of millennials want aggressive growth early in their investing careers. Two-thirds of those surveyed want to be more conservative, and 77% of all participants said they prefer to "protect my portfolio from significant losses, even if it means periods of underperforming the market."

So why haven't the large TDF shops asked investors of all ages how they really want their money managed? Why are the first-generation TDFs stuck with this egregious assumption? Plan advisers, what liability do you have in going along with this assumption?

The issues with the current TDF options on the market affect every age group. It's our job to listen to them, and provide appropriately for all of them.


We all invest to better our futures. We're only human, and if there's a threat to our future, we tend to react emotionally. Above all, investors want steady growth during good times and for their adviser to protect them against large losses in bad times.

A smart investor knows a good adviser's job is to prevent the investor from doing the wrong thing at the worst time. We can't protect against all losses, but we seek to shelter the majority of our clients' capital through smarter TDFs.

Portfolio construction needs to be aligned with investor expectations in all market environments. We must deliver what investors expect and want: portfolio growth, defensive capabilities designed to kick in only when necessary and unbiased guidance.

David M. Haviland is managing partner at Beaumont Capital Management.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Use arjuna-design' to filter and find key information on over 1,400 fee-only registered investment advisory firms.

Rank RIAs by

Upcoming Event

Mar 13



arjuna-design is honoring female financial advisers and industry executives who are distinguished leaders at their firms. These women have advanced the business of providing advice through their passion, creativity, inclusive approach and... Learn more

We are about to enter the next chapter for exchange-traded funds. What do investors expect? What do advisers wants? Jillian DelSignore of JPMorgan Asset Management offers her perspective.

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Funds that missed the January rally — some by a little and some by a lot

Here are 10 funds that whiffed when at bat against the S&P 500 index, and why they struck out.

These funds have gained more than 10% in just a month

And not all of the funds did it with tech stocks

As Finra elder-abuse rule takes effect, advisers will face awkward conversations

Regulation taking effect Monday requires reasonable effort to find trusted contact, allows brokers to stop fund disbursement.

As Trump prepares for State of the Union, 50% of advisers approve of his job performance

Percentage is 10.3 points higher than the general population approval rating.

Morgan Stanley said to be trimming 600 funds from platform

While not confirming the number of funds on the chopping block, the firm acknowledged it is culling its offerings.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at arjuna-design. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting arjuna-design.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist arjuna-design.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

401k choices osterweis strategic income fund closed end muni bond funds top 10 asset managers by aum michigan 529 plan review tiaa cref social choice bond fund pimco global opportunities fund surcharge meaning in income tax social security deceased spouse allstate international what does cfa institute stand for delaware diversified income fund class a wells fargo private bank minimum requirements how much money does fdic insure safe harbor 401 k plan definition distribution codes for form 1099 r bank of america self directed ira woodbridge mortgage investment fund 1 llc how much does northrop grumman pay how much is a white penny worth form 1099 r distribution code g ira rollover to 401k what is the yearly salary of a texas representative linsco private ledger corp good high dividend stocks turbotax additional state cost 1943 steel penny worth top 5 investors in the world can a divorced spouse collect social security can you convert a traditional ira to a roth ira nonqualified deferred compensation plan