Outside voices and views for advisers

Why 401(k) advisers should be aware of contractual language limitations

A contract may not protect advisers to the extent they believe

Jan 18, 2018 @ 11:19 am

By Marcia S. Wagner

As counsel for investment managers and investment advisers, we endeavor to draft documents precisely, making clear the obligations of our clients and seeking to limit their exposures to the extent permissible by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.

However, a recent district court decision from the Northern District of California, in the case Terraza v. Safeway, indicates limitations in the extent to which contractual language can protect investment advisers with respect to claims for breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA.

Aon, a co-defendant in the case, along with Safeway, argued that its master consulting agreement with Safeway established its robust process in providing ongoing consulting and performance evaluation, including detailed quarterly reports addressing fund structure, performance and other characteristics, quarterly meetings with the client and investment managers, and regular client communications.

While those actions are ones a prudent ERISA investment adviser would take, the district court judge was not persuaded that the terms of the document, standing alone, established that Aon had satisfied ERISA's duty of prudence. The judge explained: "That an agreement exists does not prove that it was followed, and that it might have been followed does not necessarily satisfy the duty of prudence."

Not only was the contractual language, in and of itself, insufficient to establish that the duty of prudence had been satisfied, but the same was true of the language of the detailed quarterly reports. As an example of the limitations of the quarterly investment reports, the district court concluded they would not establish the prudence of using J.P. Morgan Chase Bank benchmarks to measure the performance of the J.P. Morgan Chase Bank target-date funds, one of plaintiff's claims in the case.

(More: Excessive-fee litigation in retirement plan market moving downstream)

Second, the duty of the investment consultant was to provide prudent recommendations to the plan's fiduciary decision-makers, but the quarterly reports contained performance and other data without making any recommendations. Similarly, though Aon indicated it had made a recommendation to Safeway about a tiered investment structure, which Safeway ultimately didn't implement, the judge stated that the quarterly report didn't say anything about whether a prudent person in Aon's position would have tried to make this recommendation more than once or would have taken other steps to encourage Safeway to adopt the recommendation.

Advisers need to be aware of other limitations of contractual protection. For example, parties to a private contract are not permitted to modify the language of a statute or regulation.

For example, if there was some activity by an adviser with respect to which it was unclear whether the action constituted investment advice under the revised Department of Labor fiduciary rule, an agreement by the parties that the activity did not constitute investment advice would not preclude a court from concluding the contrary. Whether certain conduct is or isn't fiduciary in nature is a question of law, and not a matter of contract interpretation, although the parties' agreement could be a factor the court would take into account.

(More: Jerry Schlichter's fee lawsuits have left an indelible mark on the 401(k) industry)

Another limitation pertains to an individual's release of his/her claim against an investment adviser for breach of fiduciary duty. While such releases of claims by individuals are permissible, numerous courts have held that individuals do not have the authority to release the plan's claim, whether defined benefit or defined contribution, against a third party. So, the individual releasing his or her claim could still be the named plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit.

In short, while contractual language is obviously very important, investment advisers need to be aware of its limitations in certain situations.

Marcia S. Wagner is managing and founding partner of The Wagner Law Group.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Use arjuna-design' to filter and find key information on over 1,400 fee-only registered investment advisory firms.

Rank RIAs by

Upcoming Event

May 02


Women Adviser Summit

The arjuna-design Women Adviser Summit, a one-day workshop now held in four cities due to popular demand, is uniquely designed for the sophisticated female adviser who wants to take her personal and professional self to the next level.... Learn more

arjuna-design editor Frederick P. Gabriel Jr. and reporter Greg Iacurci talk about this week's cover story that looks at whether Fidelity Investments is stepping on the toes of retirement plan advisers.

Video Spotlight

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Maryland jumps into fiduciary fray

Legislation would require brokers to act in best interests of clients.

8 apps advisers love for getting stuff done

Smartphone apps that advisers are using in 2018 to run their business more efficiently.

Social Security underpaid 82% of dually entitled widows and widowers

Agency failed to tell survivors that they could switch to a higher retirement benefit later.

Is Fidelity competing with retirement plan advisers?

As the Boston-based mutual fund giant expands the products and services it brings to the retirement market, some financial advisers say the firm is encroaching on their turf.

Gun violence hits investment strategies, sparks political debates with advisers

Screening out weapons companies has limited downside.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at arjuna-design. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting arjuna-design.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist arjuna-design.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

how much is fdic insurance age to draw 401k without penalty direct rollover ira funny short retirement jokes roth ira conversion deadline non deductible 401k contributions fidelity asset allocation models lump sum distribution calculator fidelity index funds list vanguard small and mid cap index fund how to report stock dividends on tax return metlife total control account customer service who can open a sep ira fidelity international small cap opportunities fund how many times was muhammad ali married list of most expensive baseball cards can you convert a roth ira to a traditional ira state of michigan 401 k plan how to convert a traditional ira to a roth ira what is the current fdic insurance limit ira account wells fargo how much is a1943 steel penny worth vanguard index mutual fund t rowe price ira fees rare foreign coins worth money charizard first edition holographic value turbotax state tax return sep and ira contribution same year lump sum pension buyout calculator how much does fdic insure per account t rowe price target date funds invesco european small company