SPY: The ETF that's challenging Vanguard for world's biggest fund

The SPDR S&P 500 Trust is a favorite of both long-term investors and short-term traders, and a good example of how an ETF can work for all kinds of investors with all kinds of goals

Nov 29, 2014 @ 12:01 am

By Bloomberg News

The SPDR S&P 500 Trust (SPY) has always been the world's largest exchange-traded fund. Now it's moving closer to becoming the world's largest fund, period.

A surging U.S. stock market and recent inflows have made SPY the second-largest fund in the world, at $200 billion. Its assets recently topped those of the Pimco Total Return Fund (PTTRX), which is down to $171 billion in the wake of Bill Gross's exit. The largest fund in the world: the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (VTSMX), at $321 billion.*

Of the 50,000-plus mutual funds, hedge funds and ETFs in the world, Vanguard holds three of the top five spots. SPY captured the No. 2 spot without being in any 401(k) plans, which are a big and steady flow for many funds. It's a favorite of both long-term investors and short-term traders, and a good example of how an ETF can work for all kinds of investors with all kinds of goals. There are no share classes or different cost structures in the ETF world — everyone pays the same fee. SPY's investors include everyone from Bridgewater Associates LP to Dartmouth College to Treasury Secretary Jack Lew to grandmothers.

(More: Unprecedented demand for ETF tracking Chinese stocks)

Despite some dramatic daily flows and trading, the bulk of SPY's assets are very much long-term money. Assets have risen from $50 billion to $200 billion over the past decade. About $55 billion of that increase is from its 110% return. The rest — about $95 billion — is from new investments. That 10-year inflow is at least double that of any other ETF. These numbers fly in the face of the notion that SPY assets are all short-term, hot money.

Long-term investors see that SPY beats anywhere from 50% to 80% of large-cap stock managers, depending on the year, while charging a small fraction of what they charge. For every $10,000 invested in SPY, you pay $9.50 in annual fees. That compares with a minimum of $80 to $150 for a mutual fund or hedge fund.

On the other end of the spectrum, traders love SPY for its liquidity. It is the most traded security on the planet. In the past month, it has traded an average of $27 billion of shares each day. That's three times as much as Apple Inc. (APPL), the second-most-traded security in the world. SPY trades more each day than the top 10 most-traded stocks combined. It also accounts for about 20% of the equity options market.

SPY does have a significant weakness. It underperforms its peers, albeit not by much. In the past three years, SPY has gained 84.5%, which is 0.40% less than the iShares S&P 500 ETF (IVV) and 0.60% less than the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO). The main reason is its structure. IVV and VOO are open-end funds, like the majority of ETFs and mutual funds. SPY is a unit investment trust (UIT). SPY, along with some of the oldest ETFs, were created as UITs back in the early '90s, when it was the only structure acceptable to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

The most notable impact of SPY's different structure is that dividends can only be reinvested quarterly, whereas open-end funds can reinvest daily. Also, a UIT cannot lend out securities to short sellers and collect a fee. Such securities lending can bring a tiny bit of revenue that goes back into the fund and helps performance. And finally, there's SPY's slightly higher expense ratio.

VOO and IVV have also been raking in cash. In the past three years, the top three ETFs by inflow are the three that track the S&P 500. This is why SPY's ascent to the world's second-largest fund is that much more impressive. It did it with some serious competition from ETFs launched by the world's two biggest ETF issuers.

With Bill Gross out of the picture, and active management of mutual funds falling out of favor, the only thing stopping Vanguard from total world domination may be the everything-to-everyone SPY.

* This asset figure is just for the mutual fund and does not include Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF's assets. Vanguard has a unique patent in which the ETF is a share class of its mutual fund. No other company does this. Either way, the order of the top 5 funds by asset size wouldn't change. The only difference is that VTSMX would have $369 billion in assets instead of $321 billion.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Mar 13



arjuna-design is honoring female financial advisers and industry executives who are distinguished leaders at their firms. These women have advanced the business of providing advice through their passion, creativity, inclusive approach and... Learn more

Ric Edelman says the notion of retirement is changing rapidly because longevity has changed. This requires advisers to recognize that retirement is a 20th century invention and everything needs to be reconsidered.

Video Spotlight

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Is ESG investing going mainstream?

Despite advisers' misgivings, asset managers are coming around to the idea that a company's stance on environmental, social and governance issues is a good proxy for future success.

Alternative funds suddenly look a whole lot better

The market sell-off highlights the virtues of hedging.

Olympics advice from financial advisers who are Olympians themselves

Meet some of the Olympians among U.S. financial advisers, and hear their words of wisdom for those vying for the gold in PyeongChang, South Korea.

Why the new tax law amounts to a 'stealth' tax increase

The government will use an inflation measure that causes things like marginal income tax rates to rise more slowly.

Exchange-traded notes add another layer of risk

ETNs tied to volatility took a beating when stocks plunged.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at arjuna-design. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting arjuna-design.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist arjuna-design.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

charles schwab s&p 500 free stolen credit card numbers lipper fund performance highest rated vanguard funds schwab brokerage fees taxable rental income tax exempt etf form ssa-3000 western & southern mutual holding company sit dividend growth fund cfp qualification social security benefits from deceased spouse american funds growth and income portfolio class c deadline for roth ira contribution 2014 trustee to trustee transfer inherited ira how to become an allstate agent what is danny the counts net worth social security spousal benefits early retirement how much does turbo tax cost the american bankers association is an example of a american funds growth fund of america morningstar pay back social security and restart wells fargo dealer services sign up now wells fargo mutual funds review ny bank of mellon fidelity stable value fund generation x y millennials definition fidelity target date funds wells fargo mutual funds list is merrill edge good how to calculate dividend tax credit pimco floating income fund franklin templeton founding funds