Let's get real about dividend stocks

Like many good stories, the narrative is better than the reality

Sep 19, 2017 @ 3:25 pm

By Michael Finke

If you want to promote dividend stocks, you can draw from a number of good stories that can help make you and your client feel good about it. Dividends were responsible for nearly half of the total return on equity investments in the 20th century. Today's high dividend stocks provide yields that are near corporate bonds, but offer price appreciation and lower taxes. Dividend stocks outperform the average stock.

All of these stories are true. Like many good stories, however, the narrative is better than the reality. Most financial economists don't understand why anybody invests in dividend stocks. They consider dividends irrelevant, and believe that dividends appeal to investors who suffer from a behavioral bias known as narrow framing. They frame dividends as income rather than as a forced sale of stock.

To understand why academics are such a buzzkill at the dividend party, it's important to review some basic facts about dividends. First, dividends are one way a company returns cash to shareholders. The other is repurchasing shares, which accomplishes the same thing as a dividend but is unambiguously better for shareholders according to the eggheads.

Why is repurchasing better? When a firm issues a dividend, the value of the stock drops by roughly the amount of the dividend on what's known as the ex-dividend date. If I own the stock the day before the ex-dividend date, I'm entitled to the dividend. If I sell it the next day, the new owner isn't entitled to that dividend but the price has just dropped by the value of the dividend. If the dividend is $1 and the price is $100, the price is $100 on the day before the ex-dividend date and drops to $99 on the day after.

This is important because it means that if the firm hadn't paid out the $1 dividend, the company would still be worth $100. The stock value would grow over time, and investors could choose when to take money from their stock investment by deciding when to sell shares. This is what's known as synthetic dividends. If firms don't pay a dividend, I can just make my own dividend by selling off a few shares. But I can do it when I need it, not arbitrarily ever quarter.

The real problem with dividends is that if I hold a dividend stock in a taxable account, I experience a return drag that gets more significant every year. It is a common misconception that an equal capital gains and dividend tax rate means that dividend stocks aren't at a disadvantage if the investor reinvests the dividend cash. This is wrong.

When I receive a qualified dividend, I'll have to pay 15% in taxes right now. If I turn around and reinvest this in company stock, I'll have 15% less stock that can grow over time. I lose the compounding benefit from being able to achieve growth on the larger amount. Even after I eventually pay taxes on this growth, I still end up with a higher net return (roughly 12 basis points per year over time) from holding a stock with the lower dividend and an equal holding period return. Of course, the non-dividend stocks will also provide a greater benefit from a stepped-up basis at death.

This would all be a moot point if dividend stocks outperformed. They do, but that's because the types of companies that pay dividends have also outperformed historically. Even if they didn't pay a dividend.

Which companies pay dividends? Between 1992 and 2016, the average dividend yield on small cap growth stock mutual funds was 0.66%, but 2.40% on small cap value. The dividend yield on large-cap value was 2.88%, compared to 1.50% for large-cap growth. Which companies pay dividends? Value companies. Which companies outperformed during this period? Value companies. But did value stocks outperform because of their high dividends? Did low-dividend value stocks have returns that were similar to high dividend value stocks?

Meb Faber, Chief Investment Officer at Cambria Investment Management, did a recent study to find out, and the news isn't good for dividend fans. In a blog post (sympathetically titled "dividend stocks are the worst"), Faber cites research that breaks out the returns on value stocks with the lowest dividend yields and finds their return to be about the same as other value stocks, but higher when held in a taxable account – even at a 15% marginal tax rate. Compared to the highest 100 dividend paying stocks, the low-dividend value stocks trounce in total performance and demolish in after-tax performance.

Don't just take my word for it. Warren Buffett refuses to pay dividends on Berkshire Hathaway. Why? Because he believes that investors should choose when to take income from the company, and that repurchasing shares is a better way to get rid of unneeded cash. Despite many investors who would rather be told when to take income from their Berkshire Hathaway shares, Buffett makes them do the work. He'd rather not make long-run investors suffer because of the biases of investors who can't shake their need for a dividend.

Michael Finke is dean and chief academic officer at The American College.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Mar 13



arjuna-design is honoring female financial advisers and industry executives who are distinguished leaders at their firms. These women have advanced the business of providing advice through their passion, creativity, inclusive approach and... Learn more

Deputy editor Bob Hordt and senior columnist Bruce Kelly discuss the reasons for the marked shift of advisers between channels, including technology, the DOL fiduciary rule and the broker protocol.

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Capital Group, sponsor of American Funds, wins 401(k) lawsuit

Decision comes as financial services companies, especially those focused on active management, have been sued for self-dealing.

SEC considers barring aggrieved investors from suing companies

Swept up by pro-business zeitgeist, regulator seeks to reverse two-decade slump in U.S. stock listings.

Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley use contrary tactics to keep advisers

Wells is helping brokers transition to independence within the firm, while Morgan is taking them to court.

Fidelity pushes Vanguard to compete on brand in 401(k) plans

With Fidelity imposing an additional fee, Vanguard likely will look less attractive compared with comparably priced index-fund providers, advisers said.

Goldman's measure of risk appetite hits record

Global stocks and U.S. Treasuries are seeing their most "extreme" start to a year ever, bank says.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at arjuna-design. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting arjuna-design.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist arjuna-design.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

fica meaning on paycheck social security and 401k life insurance claim taxable ira distributions without penalty maximum contribution to hsa cfp exam requirements income limits while collecting social security schwab vs vanguard index funds whats a cfp how to compute social security retirement benefits 2014 maximum hsa contribution limits what is a chartered financial planner surrender life insurance policy for cash value social security benefits for a widow bank of america merrill lynch credit card irs social security disability income taxable nondeductible contributions to a traditional ira tiaa cref social choice bond fund wells fargo sign in personal banking wall street journal letters to the editor guidelines ubs financial services inc weehawken nj how to compute social security tax red rocks global listed private equity index nys 529 college savings plan etf vs mutual fund vanguard social security 1099 statement loans for college students without cosigner compare vanguard and fidelity medicare eligibility spouse under 65 lump sum versus annuity jp morgan chase pension hsa funding limits 2015 best aggressive growth etf most valuable steel penny